Doc Griffin: Shaft Myths (Part 6)

Mon, 07/16/2012 - 22:06 -- Don Trahan

Doc Griffin is back today for the sixth episode of his series on Shaft Myths.

Today's discussion deals with the myth "The more expensive the shaft is the better it will perform". As Doc explains, that simply isn't true. There are five performance characterisitcs that a club fitter will use to determine the best shaft for a particular customer:

  1. Mass. This is the overall weight of the shaft, measured in grams.
  2. Overall Stiffness/Flex. Usually defined as the amount of stiffness near the butt end of the shaft.
  3. The Bend Profile. When a shaft is under load, there are varying degrees of flex all along the length of the shaft.
  4. Weight Distribution/Balance Point.
  5. Tortional Stiffness. The degree to which the tip of the club will bend at impact.

According to Doc, there are no "bad" shafts that are sold as after market components. The level of quality from today's manufactuers is pretty high. However, a one of these shafst that does not properly match the customer's swing can become a bad shaft in a heartbeat if the fitter doesn't know his business.

Check out the video for some additional insights from Doc on what goes into building a shaft to a certain specification--I found it quite interesting.

The Surge

If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 Caveat emptor!!!

At least in the club industry there are choices and competition.
(Unlike some industries that have us over a barrel). ;-)

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Leednc,

Thanks for the info on the Aurthue Extreme. The Xcaliber is available at Golfworks. They are very affordable and have a varity of bend/flex points I like. It is hard to find an A-Flex with a mid bend point, but they have one at around $40.00 for woods and $19.00 for irons. Everything bought pre-assembled in A-Flex always seems to come in low bend points too. I've always disliked the way I hit everything too high and get little to no roll out. I will want to try these in an iron or two I'm working on.Maybe some hybrids and driver if the irons work out. Thanks again!

jlgjlg's picture

Submitted by jlgjlg (not verified) on

This is true in the golf industry as well.  In fact, most of the products that I carry have a higher "turn down" rate than the OEMs.  Also, shaft specs will vary greatly in quality of graphite, steel, and what have you.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

I was lucky and signed up with an alternate energy company for this year and my monthly rate and budget was reduced significantly. Also was able to do the same with the natural gas. I'm back to prices from a few years ago. I don't know if it will last for next year, but I've got it this year.

Edit: I like to keep my place cool, around 68* all year. It saves winter gas, but costs about a buck a day extra in the summer. To me, one dollar a day is a small price for my personal comfort.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Interesting thoughts, so I did some reading. These articles may surprise you. Maybe not.
For example what is the quality difference between clone/conterfiet and name brand clubs?
Where are most components made? Any or which ones in America and does that matter?
Seems it is currently a big issue for the Olympics and the U.S. uniforms. Makes you wonder what we we all do with 90% of our clothing if we were anti Asian/foriegn  made clothes. I personally don't care iether way. It is an 'ism', it just is regardless of how I feel.

http://www.mygolfspy.com/clone...

http://thesandtrap.com/t/38654...

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

A little sceptical Jim? Apprehensive? A 'good' personal clubfitter lives on reputation and word of mouth, no they would not talk you into a $500.00 shaft just to make profit. They would have your best interests at heart or not be in business very long. If you seriously want to consider being fit you would also want your clubs built by the same person.
Don't know who's avialable in Hawaii. You'd need to do your own research.
To know what qualities to look for, read, "The Search for the Perfect Golf Club" by Tom Wishon

Additionally I would highly recomend reading through and looking at the videos on Doc's site for a quick education on clubfitting. He also has a long distance clubfitting program that has had great reviews and may be best for someone in your location.

http://www.docgriffingolf.com/

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

Not true.  They only give prices to accounts.  Anybody, and I mean anybody can set up an account.  I know of plenty of home shop fitters that use Wishon products.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Hmmmnnn....   true, that's why I'm seriously looking at solar panels. The power co. has us over the 'barrel' here.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

I've been looking into that as well. I have a neighbor who has them on his house and his daughters. One interesting thing I found out is that you have to have the power company swap out their fancy new "smart" meters because they're too stupid to deal with bidirectional power (when your panels generate more than you can store and you sell it back to the power company). If you want, I have a name I can send you in email for a good local company.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Hmmm...Does it matter?

For the 25,000 "former" sock mill workers in this county and all of the businesses they used to shop in, and the country club where many of them played golf but now have had to give up their membership it matters a good bit.

No good answer though. There will always be someone willing to work for less that might end up with our jobs.

There used to be a big sign at the edge of town that said "Sock Capital of the World". Haven't noticed if it's still there but they might as well take it down.
http://blog.al.com/huntsville-...

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Thanks Terry. I have considered Hireko and will look at them again. Of course I have purchased multiple items from both Golfsmith and Golfworks. Why do I feel that real fitters likely have a ton of more options out there that I haven't discovered? Guess cause they buy in such volume.

Bobchipps's picture

Submitted by Bobchipps (not verified) on

Great video, Doc. Sure changed my attitude about "cheap" shafts. 

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

As for it's effect on the American worker of course it matters. Taxes, our noncompetitive situation now and all that is a lengthy subject. Believe me I wish things were different in many ways economically ect.
As for golf components, like most businesses it seems that demand and price are king regardless of the origin of the products in most cases.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

I would like to buy from Wishon, but they won't even give the prices to other than a certified PGA Fitter.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

RM:  My brother-in-law works the oil fields in Wyoming and lives in a nice house that is 100% off the grid.  He uses wind and solar power, and uses a coal/wood-fired boiler for heating.  Most of their cooking is done in one of the new microwave ovens that can also bake, etc.  Pretty cool stuff.  r2

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Good to know Doc thanks. Either the lady I spoke with was wrong or I misunderstood her. Sure wouldn't be the first time I misunderstood someone. I'll check into setting up an account.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

Doc, would you say that a good analogy is brand name drugs versus generic? Same stuff in them, 1/3 the price, with the brand name manufacturers saying that the extra money is going to pay for all of the R&D work to create the product.

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

"Clones" and counterfeit are two very distinctive groups.  Counterfeit clubs are without a doubt of significant lesser quality.  I also don't think any club heads are made in the good ole' USofA any longer.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

That's probably a good idea on their part and the best way to make sure the product is presented in the best light (or at least as well as possible).

You would be surprised (or maybe not) at some of the dumb fitting ideas and experiments some of the backyard fitters around here come up with.

Then I'm sure at some point someone is going to try one of those poorly designed clubs and blame a lack of performance on the name on the shaft or the head.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Thanks Doc. Good to know we can set something up with Wishon if desired.

jim's picture

Submitted by jim on

Where do you find a "good" clubfitter here in Honolulu, Hawaii? What is the normal charge for a clubfitter, excluding the cost of the shaft, grip, etc? Does a good clubfitter get you a $50 shaft or a $500+ shaft just to increase his profit?

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 I would like to figure out a way to get from point A to point B for less.

They say you can save a lot on electricity by unplugging every appliance not in use. I bet 99% of the available outlets have something plugged into them at any given time in our house.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Alternate energy company? Don't think we have that choice here. By alternate you don't mean solar do you? What I'm refering to is setting up an entire system that will pay for itself in a few years. Still researching and looking at it but there is one guy out there that says we can build our own (even just a few panels at a time). One says you'll eventually be "off the grid" and another says when you have too much it is shared with your neighbors and you get a credit as you go. Still looking but I guess we get 30% re-inburst by Gov.
................ just looked at another hour or so of you tube stuff on solar and wind turbines, et. Crazy cool. Has my wheels turning anyhow.

shortgamewizard's picture

Submitted by shortgamewizard (not verified) on

This shows how shaft manufacturers are no different from other businesses whose goal is to make as much profit off the consumer for the shareholders as possible. No regard for what is best for those in the masses. Sad ethics.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Yes, I think it is there way of ensuring quality control measures and protecting their name.

P0kerstar's picture

Submitted by P0kerstar (not verified) on

virtually all heads and shafts are made in the same handful of places. a $5 steel shaft comes off the same assembly line as a $30 steel shaft. a forged head from golfsmith or golfworks or hireko come from the same factories as mizuno....

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Thanks Lynn. Enjoyed the the re-affirmation that costs do not particularly equate to quality. As an amature fitter (or as Terry humbly says, 'assembler') I am not in a financial position to buy expensive components to build clubs. I have been looking carefully to find affordable shafts and clubheads. Shafts over-all are really easy to find on the net. Heads however are not. If anyone has any reliable sites or suggestions for buying heads alone I would love some suggestions. Anyhow I found the following site for affordable shafts. they have other components too but it was the shafts that drew me. The shafts I bought there allowed me to completely re-shaft the entire set for my wife with a low bend ladies shaft. She has improved dramatically since the switch. It has really helped her get the ball higher and further in the air. Something ladies and those with slower swings struggle with.

http://www.diamondtour.com/gol...

Also switched out a more expensive shaft from my adams hybrid and adams 3 wood with great results

For my 3 wood;
http://www.diamondtour.com/rev...

and my hybrid;
http://www.diamondtour.com/gol...

Yes two of my choices were only $9.99 each but turns out they were as good as they're reviews. So yes, price has very little to do with shafts that are after market quality.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I don't know whether there are any actual differences in brands that come from the same factory or not with golf equipment but I do know that in a couple of industries I've worked in the quality of raw materials and the acceptable specs varied a lot, depending on the customer.

Same factory, same production line, very different finished product.