Swing Up On All Shots

Wed, 03/28/2012 - 22:27 -- Don Trahan

Dick Braman sent in a question regarding the act of pre-loading heavy right when setting up to the ball. He has been having good success off of the tee, but when he plays from the fairway, he often hits chunky shots.

"I have been playing with your swing for over a year. I use the neutral grip, and I have mostly eliminated slicing the ball off the tee. I hit most of the fairways most of the times---a really great improvement over other swings I've used. My question, however relates to the preloading of the right leg. I use this on the tee with good weight shifting results, but it does not work for me on the fairway. I frequently chunk the hit. Question: do you preload on fairway shots? If so, how do I correct the problem. I don't have the chunk problem if I don't preload, but also don't get the good weight shift."

For Dick and anyone else who may be having a similar problem hitting their irons from the fairway, take this into consideration. When using the Peak Performance Golf Swing, we swing up with all the clubs. We don't want to consciously hit down on the ball because the downswing is actually the free part of the swing. So why waste more energy trying to drive down into the ball? I think Dick was seeing success off of the tee because he was able to tee the ball up. This forces him to swing up, as opposed to hitting down on balls in the fairway. Remember, we want to take shallow divots and nip the ball off the ground. A lot of players don't like to hit off of mats, but it doesn't bother me at all because I'm using the PPGS.

Pre-loading heavy right should always be part of your setup position. The only time this changes is when you're on a hill. In that case, you would set up with the hill so you don't bottom out behind the ball, or top it. Take a look at the video and you'll see that regardless of the club in my hand, I'm always swinging up.

Keep it vertical,

The Surge!
Don Trahan
PGA Master Professional

If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

WestOz John's picture

Submitted by WestOz John (not verified) on

This is not about the current topic but more a personal problem that I hope someone may be able to offer some advice.  I have been practicing the PPGS method for about 15 or 16 months now and have had quite a bit of success.  My major problem is persistently  hitting left (I am a right-handed golfer), rarely slicing.  I do think the fact that I do not have a left eye may be causing me to rotate my shoulders left in setup although I can't see it myself.  I work fairly hard at Don's alignment, using alignment pointers even when practicing on the course.
Does anyone have any similar problem?

John Thompson

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

 Good to hear from you again Ronnie. Like Steve, I don't have much faith or use for a 60*. I use a 48* PW. 52* GW, 56* SW, and for any and all green side bunkers, my trusty Alien Wedge. My wedges are Tom Wishon and offer some uniqueness to their design.
http://wishongolf.com/designs/...

Like you, my putting is always an ongoing battle in which I have learned two specific things over the years. I do best with center shafted, face balanced styles and a very oversize grip. I presently like the Two Thumbs, but installed sideways with the widest part against the inside palms.

Keep fighting for improvement Ronnie, and give us a post every now and then. Best wishes for life and golf.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

That's a lotta golf in one day, Dick. Congratulations. Out here there aren't many courses I could get through more than twice in a day as slow as people play. Unless I were up to paying $200 a round. :)

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

That is way to cool. I made a homemade job last year with 2 good bearing fitted tight inside conduit about 6" apart with a small bearing to pull down the tip. I was proud of it and showing it off to a friend while assembling a club for him. It was a light weight true ace deathstick thin walled and when i pulled the tip bearing the shaft snapped right at the end of the conduit. Damn was I shocked. I bought him another and learned a lesson. I do have a R9 with a Sk fiber Helium shaft that I love. I am not a fan of adjustable heads or TM for that matter, but I was messing around with the adjustments and apparently got the spine right and WOW what a difference. The logo was facing the target. 

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Great to here all is going well Dick. 72 holes?!! Wow! It's good to be Dick:)
Sounds like it's all coming together for your PAT. You are living the golfers dream life. Fun stuff. Thanks for sharing and keep us posted.

548991's picture

Submitted by 548991 (not verified) on

I'm not the foremost authority , it may be , your club striking the ball , outside  -  into the ball pulling it to the left , i don't think it's your eye , when our , " nose at ball,"  at moment of impact , you may be looking away , lifting
your head  to early ..  Jon

Termides's picture

Submitted by Termides (not verified) on

I like those Wishon's. Now you have me thinking and I dug out an old 2 thumb grip I have had lying around for years. Have you tried a belly putter?

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

That's what you get for living in a place where too many people play golf. Ha ha ha!

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

It's a long way from the 287 yards DJ hit on 13 today, and on a green with several bunkers around.

I'm going to have to man up a little more. Ha ha!

P.S. Those driving stats are very misleading on how far they can hit a golf ball. Sometimes they are laying up, and it's quite a bit more important that they control their shots than it is for me. If I hit a bad shot it will cost me from $0 to $10. If they hit one it may cost thousands, or hundreds of thousands, or their job.

I feel pretty confident that even most of the guys on the Champions Tour would blow me away in a long ball contest (except with irons, I can hit those pretty far). ;-)

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

To clarify, are you pulling it left or is it hooking or curving from right to left?
Does it start left and fly straight left? Understanding the 9 ball flight laws won't fix the problem right away but it can help you diagnose the swing results you are currently getting. After understanding what your ball flight is then we may be able to give you a better answer. Read and watch the following links below carefully. I hope they help you see if it is your path, clubface angle or a combination. You will understand better if your swing is inside out, outside in or perhaps slightly outside in with a slightly closed clubface. Additionally by examining your divots and video taping your swing you will begin to get a clearer picture of what's causing your shots to fly left.
It could also turn out to be that your clubs are too upright which could cause your shots to fly left. I know it's quite alot to consider but it may help you on this crazy journey called golf. Get back to us and you'll be pleasantly surprised that good advice can be had here.

http://www.vipgolfacademy.com/...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Hey Mr. Ronnie! Nice to here from you. I also have the habit of using my PW48* as much as possible because I am very confident with it. However I often play a course that has greenside bunkers that are not on the side but in front of the green and I need to get some loft. I also don't like the 60* and play a 53 and 58*. I have really started following the Kenny Knox videos and am forcing myself to get better and more confident with those more lofted clubs. It's working. I have found that the 53 gives me between 75-85 yards and the 58 from 65-75. I usually keep my swing to only 1/2- 3/4's with both for more control. Have made both of them more versitile by grinding the heals and toe bounce to a lesser degree. That really helps when I have to make the 58 more like a 60-62 and flop it over a trap or hill from say only 20/30 yards. It takes practice and commitment but that's what I have to do to improve my game this year.
Hope you're well and it's good to hear from you
PMG

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

I might be able to get that many rounds in mid-summer out here. Surprisingly, not that many people want to be outdoors for hours on end when it's 115*.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 I hate the ones where the slope leading up to the green has thick rough and soft wet ground and there is no option of bumping it into the slope.

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Probably sounds like a broken record by now but you are probably swinging at the ball from either the top or at least too close to the top.

If you let the left arm and club (butt end first) fall toward the toe line far enough at some point it becomes impossible to pull the ball. Of course taken too far you will hit the ball from the inside out and hit the ball to the right so it does take some practice to know just how far the club can fall butt end first before rotating toward the ball, and it's not the same for everybody.

I would never presume to know what it's like to have only one eye and what the lack of depth perception would be like or what it might cause.
 I do know what it's like to pull the left shoulder out sooner than I would like. I would normally like to have my shoulders pretty much square to the target line at the split second of impact but I have to let my shoulders open slightly to save the stress on the back of my right shoulder caused by the arm swinging across the chest with the shoulders square. I just have to keep the left shoulder opening early to the very minimum, and more importantly make extra effort to let the club go through the ball on line without pulling off of the ball.

If you get a slow motion video you should be able to see just what's going on and if the first move of the arm in the FUS is to fall straight down or go toward the ball or, heaven forbid, come over the top.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

Get your Shot Trackers up, as DJ will be teeing off in about 10 minutes. I've been tracking the McDowell and Westwood group this morning, and Lee must have had one hell of a good kick forward on his tee shot on 4 (his 13th hole). It went 367 yards.

EDIT: And, as usual, I make two mistakes. Well, I made one and Tracker was slow updating for the other. The 367 yards for Lee Westwood was actually 2 shots, as his first went in the bunker. Stupid human error updating the information. ;-) And, I forgot that the event is in Texas, so DJ won't be teeing off for another hour.

Bob Dense's picture

Submitted by Bob Dense (not verified) on

Surge:
Do you have a certified PPGS instructor in the Phoenix, Scottsdale area?  If so can you email me who they are?  Thanks,
I'm a student of your's and have been to a couple of your schools.  Thanks

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Steve, I was typing and looking up the references I gave below while you were too. Kinda cool that we were simultaneously being helpful at the same time. Neat thing about it is we hadn't read each others answers first so both are independant takes on the question from John. Your answer focuses more on the likely problem and a solution and I came from a let's get to know more first perspective. Both helpful and we both shared the importance of 'seeing' what's going on by video.
All good. Have a great night Steve:)

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

Just got back from playing 9 holes. Not one soul on the golf course but me. Two guys were leaving as I was starting.

BTW. May be the most comfortable 2 under par I ever had for 9 holes. No bogies and not even a good chance for a bogie. Hit all fairways but one and it was on a hole that didn't matter much and I was in good shape for a second that I hit to 4 feet and made the putt for one of my birdies. Hit 7 greens and the two I missed were by a few inches and I could putt them.

Only weakness was I was off both left and right on some shots of just over 100 yards and left myself longer putts than should have been and I left two of them dead center and a few inches short.
Really starting to get comfortable with what I am having to do to protect my shoulder a little.

Edit: Just watched hole 13 on shot tracker and now I'm mad. Thought I was getting somewhere but I don't think I can hit a 590 yard hole in two unless it was on an airport runway or something. :-(

Bob Dense's picture

Submitted by Bob Dense (not verified) on

Surge:
I've asked this question before, but your answer hasn't soaked in yet.  I'm hitting behind the ball with all clubs when the ball is on the grass.  I sense that I'm sinking down on the back swing and I don't know why or how to correct it.  I've experimented with ball location in my stance.  It doesn't seem make a difference.  All my clubs are from Doc Griffin, and I like them.
I've tried to obey your instructions regarding heavy load right, with limited turn and I concentrate on not rotating into the SBG.  I tend to hit the ball slightly right with a little slice, unless I concentrate very hard on rotating my forearms over on the down swing at impact.  Then I seem to be able to hit the ball more down the center.  But most of the time, I'm bouncing off the grass into the ball and this reduces power and distance.  What is the magical answer?  Thanks
Bob

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

Off topic. I started playing a 52,56,60 degree wedge set. I have had nothing but problems with my short game. I always used PW and SW when I started playing. Now I am just confused. I don't hit them solid enough the get the yardage for each. I used to adjust my PW by choking down or adjusting my takeaway. I had no clue what bounce was. I am thinking about going back to that. Are you guys using all those wedges. Now that I hit driver in play and straight irons the short game is killing me. Don't even mention my big nemesis putting. I have a plumbers neck, blade and mallet and just ordered a belly grip and shaft. I guess it will always be somthing wrong. 

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

DJ tees off at 12:20 am eastern time at the Shell Thursday. Let's hope he can build on making the cut last week and put 4 good days together. We're pulling for you Deej.

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

Sand don't bother me it is pitch shots 20' straight up with little room to stop. I have to flop the 60 or try bumping it into the bank but then you have the run out to deal with. Did you grind the heels yourself? I see clubs that are D grind and C grind and I don't know the difference. 

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

Yeah, give me 100 yards of cart path roll and I could do it. :) Actually, I was once hole high on a 670 yard hole in two. Of course, 400+ yards of the hole was down a 30-something* slope and my second shot hit the cart path crossing at the bottom of the hill and bounced up to the green. Amazing how far a ball will bounce off of a cart path when it has several hundred feet of momentum behind it.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

Anyone looking for this information can find it via the Instruction & Club Fitting tab at the top of any page here. The answer, though, is no. There are currently no certified instructors in Arizona. 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 Good to see your comment again Ronnie.
I have those three wedges but stay away from the 60* whenever I can and when I am not playing well I leave it at home.

My son is a much better player than I am and he hasn't carried his 60* in over a year.

I am pretty decent with the wedges but used to struggle a lot with them and they weren't going the distances they should go. Found out I was flipping the club at the ball instead of just taking a nice smooth swing. They are the easiest clubs to get the club head too far forward in relation to the hands at impact because they are the shortest clubs. Try leaving the 60* out of the bag for a while and practicing what will almost feel like knockdown shots with the others with the hands leading at impact. Chances are the hands won't be leading nearly as much as you think and may even end up being just right.

Feels like my hands are WAY in front of my club head at impact but in reality they are not and I hit my wedges very high and very long.

Dick's picture

Submitted by Dick (not verified) on

Surge Nation.

What a day it was for golf in central Oklahoma boys and girls.  I started off on the putting green at 715 this morning, and got out of my cart at dark.

Now for the rest of the story.  After 15 min. of good stretching, I putted, chipped, and hit balls on the range until 9 AM.  At 907 we teed off on our South course.  The guy I was playing with had to go to work at 1 PM, so he only got to play 27 holes with me.  After he left, I played the back nine on the North course by myself.  I then hooked up with two other guys that work at the course.  We played 18 holes together.  By that time  Donna was off work, and she came out and rode with me while I played another 18.  Altogether I got in 72 holes today.  We got up to about 80° today, and the winds were 15 to 20.  The best news is that if I took any two rounds of the four rounds I played today and put them together, I would have passed the PAT.

It seems to really be coming together for me right now.  Only a week and a half to go.  I just have to hope I can put together two great rounds on 9 April.

This was the most golf I've ever played in one day in my whole life.  I've played three rounds on the same day several times since I started using the Surge  Swing.  I have a home inspection to do tomorrow morning, and I should be able to hit the course by about 1 PM.  I plan on playing till dark.  Friday morning I am playing with two of the young pros at the course, then working in the clubhouse till dark.  That is what my schedule is gonna look like until after the PAT.

I am living proof that the Surge Swing is body friendly.  As you know, I had not been able to play golf for nearly 20 years due to severe back and shoulder injuries from a service related accident.  That all changed when I found the Surge a year and a half ago.  For the last year I've averaged 4 – 6 rounds a week, with no pain.  During the years when I was unable to play golf, I would go out about once a year and hit a bucket of balls.  Being uneducated, I was still using the rotational swing.  I would not be able to get out of bed for 2 to 3 days every time.  I will admit that a couple of months ago I decided to see if possibly my back had just gotten stronger.  I went to our driving range and hit 30 balls with four different clubs, using my old rotational swing.  I just had to know if my back was better or if it really was the Surge Swing.  You can probably guess the results.  I couldn't get out of bed the next day.  I gave it a couple of days, and then went out and played two rounds in the same day using the Surge Swing.  No pain at all.  Imagine that, it really is this swing.

Keeping it vertical, and playing golf all day long, in Oklahoma,
Dick

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Yes, I have a belly putter and a longer shoulder putter in the basement where they belong. Neither offered any better results for me. I use a left hand low and fully extended left arm with no elbow bend. No wrist's, just shoulder pendulum motion. I also have a precise set-up routine that I use for all putts. I like the Two Thumbs sideways because the larger flatter side resting in the palm of my left hand, feel more like a paddle handle than a cue stick. For me, it just feels easier to keep the face square with the wider surface against the inside of my lead hand. Having the narrower surface between the palms, also keeps the palms closer together and seems to benefit with better feel and control between the two hands.

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

The magical answer is that you're losing your spine angle for some reason. You need to get video of your swing to see what you're actually doing. It only hurts for a little while the first time you see yourself swing on video. 

Also keep reviewing this video: http://swingsurgeon.com/DailyV...

steve greenwald's picture

Submitted by steve greenwald on

This was an interesting tip, Surge, and your swing has saved my back!  But let me ask the flip side of the coin vis-a-vis the fat shot.  I find myself hitting it thin off the fairway with my irons.  What would cause this and how do I correct it?  Help!!

Sincerely,

Steve Greenwald

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

You may still need your pitching wedge in there. Those are usually around 48*. I carry PW (48*), Gap Wedge (52*) and alternate between two 56* wedges--my old sand wedge for places with soft sand, as it has a lot of bounce, or a newer 56* wedge with much less bounce when the sand is firmer. I've never carried a 60* wedge, but I don't really see the point when I can lay the 52* or 56* as open as I want depending on the situation to get that extra loft. 

As Steve says below, watch your technique with the wedges. Many people have a problem of flipping at the ball with the hands in an effort to get it to fly higher, which causes all sorts of problems. The shaft lean on wedges keeps the hands ahead of the ball through impact if you just swing normally, or even as Steve says imagine that you're hitting a punch shot to keep your hands from releasing early.

90+% of amateur golfers should not carry a 60* wedge, in my opinion. It's just going to drive them nuts for the benefit of 1 decent shot out of 20 tries.

Dick's picture

Submitted by Dick (not verified) on

Surge.

I just wanted to let you know that purchasing the short game, situational shots, and working the ball videos was one of the best decisions I've ever made.  Three times today  I had to hit my ball out of someone else's divot.  On two other occasions my approach shot landed short of the green.  Since they just punched our greens, they are watering them very heavily.  The area in front of the greens is very wet and soft.  My ball was completely below the surface.  All I could see was the very top of the ball.  I hit it just like you showed us in the video for hitting out of a divot.  It worked great all five times.  That type of shot would've scared me to death before watching your video.

Thanks so much for all you do for us,
Dick

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

I did grind them myself. I did alot of research and worked carefully. In harmony with what Kenny Knox talks about with his wedges. Decided to just take the leap and start learning club fitting bit by bit. Having fun.

kybob's picture

Submitted by kybob (not verified) on

I need some help.  In watching some of the slo-mo shots of the pros - I see where most of their divots are a couple of inches in front of the ball - and Don teaches and I try to just pick the ball off the surface.  I understand that the pros get lots of backspin by hitting the ball first - especially the shorter irons.  I don't seem to get much backspin using the Surge Swing.  Am I doing something wrong?  I am 6' 7" - does that matter?

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

First check your ball position. If it's too far forward or back, and you maintain a good spine angle, you will often catch the ball thin. Alternately, you could be losing your spine angle, pulling yourself back from the ball and swinging in with the club just enough higher that you catch the ball thin. 

This is the preferred miss, as the ball still generally travels a good distance in the intended direction. It can be problematic with wedges, as a thin wedge shot will often fly too far.

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

I fought the flipping problem for a while but now if I am fairly close to the green I use my overlap putting grip and think of extending the palm of my right hand toward the target as long as possible while turning through the shot playng the ball off my right toe and somtimes lifting my right heel off the ground to get the weight on the left side. I got the 60 because a course I often play has elevated greens that run off in every direction leaving serious uphill lies where you need to stop the ball fast with a high lob. Awesome when it works but not often enough. I shot a good 40 my last nine on the back side, had 6 birdie putts inside 10 feet, never made a one and 4 putted a par 3. I had a total 42 putts for the 18. Tell me that don't bring tears to your eyes. Getting close to the green strikes fear in my heart almost as bad as a 3 foot putt. 

Russty Kiwi's picture

Submitted by Russty Kiwi (not verified) on

Its all very simple. If it goes right-  its a slice
                              If it goes left - its a hook
                              If it goes straight- its a miracle

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

Some here get sensitive about that, but I make all my clubs. Not only is it a great hobby there is great satisfaction involved. I recommend every one try it. I started with basic chop saw, vise and clamps, small airless compressor for blowing grips on, steel 48" ruler, propane and bench grinder, the majority from Harbor Freight and mostly components from Hireko or Golfsmith. Beats fishing right now. I love it when my buds talk junk and I kick their butts. I know why Lynn loves his job. If I were a younger man I would try to get into a school to get into it properly. The clubfitter is now disrespectful to me when I go up to the range to hit balls even though I never tell anyone there anything about my clubs. I had a guy asked me what my clubs were and I heard his buddy say Walmart. I was hitting Dynacraft Profit Tour forged carbon heads with Apollo Phantom shafts from Hireko.  

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

With the PPGS, you should still be hitting the ball first. The spin comes from the relationship between the angle of attack and the angle of the face of the club, and just how much you can compress the ball at impact. You don't WANT the kind of backspin the pros get, because even they have trouble controlling it (ask Kyle Stanley). You can get plenty of spin with the PPGS, especially because you will usually be bringing the ball in higher and softer, so it will stop relatively quickly most of the time. 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 Took me forever to submit that reply. My internet  was out (again) and I was trying to pick up my neighbor's and  they live probably a couple hundred yards away and it kept cutting out.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

 Robert and Ronnie,

I forget whether I've mentioned it or not, but this is one of my latest buys for club assembly. I have had a Golfsmith swing weight scale for years, and as you know just got the lie and loft machine, which is still in the box. At the rate I'm going it may be winter before I can ever get full use of it.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Profes...

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

My problem is the second shot. I just don't seem to have the pop anymore with the 3 wood but I hate to change anything because I have never hit it straighter, but usually only for about 260 yards.

Doc Griffin's picture

Submitted by Doc Griffin (not verified) on

I'll throw in the fitter's answer.  If your clubs are too short or too long it can also cause thin shots.  The root cause for either would be the same which is the change in spine angle that Robert mentioned.

Ronniemac's picture

Submitted by Ronniemac on

That was the Ballantyne Course near Qual Hollow, It is public and right now $40 for 18. You probably heard of Dana Radar Golf school. She teaches there and rated one of the best in the Good Old USA. 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

 I was watching a video of a golf instructor one time and he was talking about how his dad couldn't hit the ball very far because he had a bad back, even though he was a strong man.

All I could think was that he could have saved his dad a lot of trouble if he had just told him to use a Surge swing.

Seems that even though I am seeing more people that are putting certain aspects of the PPGS into their swings, and are less laid off in the back swing, more quiet in the legs, and even looks like a slightly flared foot or two, they all still insist that it takes a "full turn" to hit the ball.

Pages