Do Not Hit Down

Fri, 05/27/2011 - 10:50 -- Don Trahan

What is it with golf publications? I understand they need to report on the latest swing that promises you an extra 50 yards or gives you the ultimate tip to sink that 30 foot putt. Fine. If that advice helps, try it. But hitting down on the ball? Get real.

Hitting down on the ball means deep divots - a Surge Swing no-no - and it just doesn'€™t make sense.

From the top of the backswing to the finish I call the FUS, the forward upswing. Everything in the swing is focused on the T-Finish. Impact is just a part of the process.

I think this video will help you overcome the '€œdownswing'€ ideas and come '€œup'€ with the right answers.

Keep it vertical,

The Surge!

Having trouble viewing this YouTube video? We are beta testing a new video delivery system. If you can't view the YouTube video above try CLICKING HERE. You must allow popups from this site for the link to work.

Blog Tags: 

Comments

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

Thanks, Hal, very nice reply. Some people,like T mentions below whine about anything. Most haven't purchased the swing series videos and have no plans to do so, yet they expect Don to just unload all his knowledge without compensation. I, for one, appreciate the time he takes out of his busy schedule to offer these free tips "from his back porch" and like the personal feel that they give to the tip or thought of the day. Should I ever find the time, I intend to take a school in the future, hopefully within 3 years as that is my time left before I retire. I want to get as good as possible before then so I can play the game to my fullest potential. I think this will be a great way to further bond and develop my relationship with my son, Joshua. For the regulars here, we did get back the clinical results Wednesday & Joshua does indeed have Asperger's.
 I guess, I'll go ahead and make this my main comment for the video. Thank you,Surge, for today's video. I'm reminded of when Jesus would give the masses a parable and then the disciples would question him about it. "Though seeing, they do not see. Though hearing, they do not hear." It's pretty simple to all those that have purchased your series and followed along daily( or near about) what you mean by "Do Not Hit Down" on the ball. We know your style, semantics and can follow what your saying without a hitch and often find it quite humorous when you get excited and occasionally "misspeak", i.e., calling your left arm your right. It's no biggie. So in closing, Surge, thanks for the tip about not hitting down on the ball.
We're going from the BUS to the T-finish via the FUS and swinging through the ball , as if it isn't even there.
Happy golfing everyone,
Boog

"Put up or shut-up"

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Good night to you Dick, I'll be up at 5am to play 9 before 8am and work from 9-7pm.
PMG

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

Glenn:  Just go to the top of this blog, and on the right side you will see a box to type in "key word or phrase".  Type in what you are looking for and hit the square green button below the key word box.  All posts relating to that subject will be shown.  Enjoy.  Also, buy the video series that the Surge sells ( it is a very reasonable cost).  Everything you need to know is in there.  Good luck to you.  R2 

Keith's picture

Submitted by Keith on

That's the first time I've heard the SBG referred to as behind the heels.  The impression I always got from what he said was anything behind the toes, which I didn't agree with.  Maybe I missed it if that's in the manual somewhere.

Dick Lee's picture

Submitted by Dick Lee (not verified) on

Boog

I echo what Robert said.

You are one of my heroes.
Dick

Amos's picture

Submitted by Amos (not verified) on

Robert F:

   I hate to admit it, but I have been accused of being "that Old Sandbagger AMos" on a few occasions.   LOL

    Amos

Henkiolento1's picture

Submitted by Henkiolento1 (not verified) on

I too purchased a tour striker 8 iron. Don did a segment on the tour striker and said one's hands would have to be way out in front of the ball at address. This is absolutely wrong. I have my hands in a normal address position. If we are swinging correctly our hands are slightly ahead of the club head at impact. This produces solid contact. You are not actually hitting down and yes if you swing with Don's thought of hitting up you achieve the same result. Everyone who has tried this club loves it. However it is not difficult to hit this iron correctly and the price may be a bit steep for the benefit gained unless of course one has a totally disconnected uncoordinated swing.

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

I recall hearing one of the older pros (possibly Trevino, or atleast that era) saying you have to be able to play your home course CONSISTENTLY at 3 under par or better, from the TIPS, to even think about going to the next level. (mini tours?)

I'm not there yet. LOL

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Steve, you and Phil Mickleson have alot in common! He never needs a fairway offf the tee. Say thanks Steve :)

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

Thanks gman, well said and oh so true. I have recently gone back to zealously reviewing the many purchased video lessons I have from Don. I have them all including both putting videos. It comes out I buy it because I know it is the swing for me and Surge has several decades of applied golf wisdom that always makes sense and never stops helping every time I view and practice these timeless lessons. Looking back over the past 3 years I think the grand total is less than $110.00. Last night a family dinner we had though joyful cost over $300.00 and my golf did not improve one stroke LOL! Because my timing was right a couple years ago I was able to score the Junior Blurprint video. Though it only makes up a small percentage of my vast Surge library, I feel he could charge 100.00 for it alone. The back portch and vast archives of tips? Wow he really could charge more over-all. Don't worry Surge Nation, the prices will stay reasonable because that's how Surge rolls.

Keith Kent's picture

Submitted by Keith Kent (not verified) on

I do yes, I will give them a look over again, now I know what to focas at this point on hopefully the left arm/wrist will quickly improve, even though I am trying to keep the palms perpendicular at this point I still am struggling, so wonder if it is a strength issue too because it is a new movement. Getting in the position in the first place is key I know that.
I am going to slightly adjust my grip, right arm position & loaded heavy right, lift the club whilst turning my shoulders and waist. Simple! Ha ha   

Keith Kent's picture

Submitted by Keith Kent (not verified) on

I have never had a hit down swing thought but it helps me to have a back swing, downswing and forward upswing post impact. Backswing and FUS just don't do it for me for some reason as I see the swing in three parts but I see why you may want to elimate the word down pre impact.
But the word down may help me trying to get the club in the slot as I am casting the club forward at the top of the backswing creating a out to in swing path.
Regards

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

David,
On the comment page it is the UTUBE version. The 2 versions are generally available for any video in the last month. Tech Crew are working towards improvements and there are growing pains. Look around for a link if you can't find something or ask again. Lots of good samaritans here to help out.
Good Luck
Dan

Robert F's picture

Submitted by Robert F (not verified) on

First, Surge doesn't say not to take any divot, just not to take a big divot. The same advice as Moe Norman, whom many believe to be the best ball striker to ever live, and the same as Tom Watson, a guy who has had some small success in the game of golf.

People will take any advice and stretch it well past the breaking point, which is the common problem with "hit down on the ball." Your average Joe Golfer goes out there and figures the problem with his ball striking is that he's clearly not sufficiently hitting down on the ball and next thing you know he's swinging like Charles Barkley trying to get to China.

The objective is to hit the ball as close as possible to the bottom of the swing arc. Period. That's where you get the greatest acceleration and the cleanest contact. Also, though, Surge wants us to focus on finishing the swing up to the T finish. We release up through impact. Yes, the club is technically still descending slightly or level for a couple inches after the ball, but the thought we as players should have is getting to the finish, not stopping in the middle to dig a new drainage ditch.

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

Kevin, my back and elbow both felt better today so when I got home the lab & I went outdoors. I went through my swingrite warm up and then dropped a foamer on the ground. Started my swing tune and got to my swing note and let it fly. I made sure I was skipping the rock but was hitting hooks for some reason. Trying to determine what the culprit was for those,maybe I was subconsciously steering the clubhead that way to avoid Honey, she seemed over-eager today to retrieve and was breaking from her kennel/sit position about the time I bumped. Perhaps, it's the offset in my current sticks, I think the ball position was good, nadir was just in front of the ball which was in the middle of my stance. I was also using an 8 iron. I don't think I was early with my release but will diagnose it all soon enough.I was pleasantly suprised , however, I thought the first few swings with the "rock toss" would give me some problems like chunking but it did not. I felt like I was getting into the slot well also.
 Boog

yeah, I know, I need some fresh videos of the swing,they're coming soon.

Dick Lee's picture

Submitted by Dick Lee (not verified) on

To the Miner brothers

You guys should get together and give each other a lesson.

Never mind, what is that old saying? 

Two miners don't make a major.

Dick

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

More misconceptions. The club head at the top is not supposed to be over the toe line. The toe line is where the outside of the tree is, and where the vertical lift begins. However the turn is not quite finished at that point so as the lift is finished and the turn completed the club ends up on the outside of the tree which puts it over the soft part of the shoulder and not the toe line.

Roy Reed's picture

Submitted by Roy Reed (not verified) on

T:  Great minds think alike!  Being an old electrical worker, I thought about using the Uni-strut.  I was over at Home Depot on Tuesday and seen most of the parts you've mentioned.  I purchased them (cost about $15.00) and proceeded to build one and it works great.  And, like you said, it is heavy duty!   Problem solved.   Hope your weekend is great and thanks for watching out for me - I need all the help I can get!  LOL,LOL  R2  

Kelly's picture

Submitted by Kelly on

I too have the Tour Striker Pro model 5-iron. This model places the striking area even higher on the club than the regular model, making it appear to really require a downward strike. Like you, I really like what this aid has done for how solidly and accurately I'm striking the ball. HOWEVER, I do not want to "strike down" on the ball because I don't think it is good for a 48 year old's back, wrists, and forearms. So, I asked Martin Chuck about the issue of hitting down on the ball, asking him to explain his approach considering Moe Norman's suggestion that your divot should be no more than a strip of bacon in front of the ball.

Martin's reply was, "Bacon strips, not pork chops, indeed!" He went on to say that he does not believe in "hitting down" per se, and does not teach it. He said that the "hitting down" mantra was something that the marketing department grabbed hold of. He said that his intention with the Tour Striker is to get your hands into proper position, ahead of the ball. This is, admittedly, a bit of semantics because having your hands ahead of the ball create a descending blow, you do not have to go "steeply" into the ball to get into this position.

Surge uses the same semantic "sleight of hand." He says to hit up to a T-finish, which may be interpreted as an upward blow; it's not. The "swinging up to the T-finish" part of Surge's swing is to promote standing up AFAP after contact (to take the pressure off the back). The "bump of the hips" part of the swing naturally moves the bottom of your swing slightly ahead of the ball, which means that you are still descending into the ball when you strike it. It is just that it is a shallow strike, which is promoted by both Surge and Martin Chuck.

Robert Meade's picture

Submitted by Robert Meade (not verified) on

I had been watching DJ's day on PGA shot tracker during his first nine. The telecast on Golf Channel was saying that 1 over was probably the cut. Then my wife and I went to the gym and I followed DJ on my DroidX phone and his shot by shot game. I was living and dying with every well hit/ poor hit good putt, missed putt, par saves and bogies. When he went back to even for the day with # 7 par 5 coming up I thought birdy time. A rare poor drive lead to a par. Then still even for the day but 2 over I felt he had to birdy 8 or 9 ( (his 17/18). Bogied 8 and birdied his last hole # 9. Even for the day but 2 over for the tourny. Then when I checked on line at home just now, 3 over is now the cut line! He's in by a stroke. Hopefully things will get better over the week end. Tough course on a windy day. He hung on well today.

Boogm's picture

Submitted by Boogm (not verified) on

Kevin, thanks for the in-depth analysis of your session of swing experiments. As soon as my back allows me to swing again without further aggravation I shall give do a little experimenting of my own. Like a dummy, last night as I was working my swingrite indoors I did an uh-oh and am feeling it today.I started on the low 9 setting and worked my way down to where I normally do and was about 3 swings into that setting when for some unknown reason I didn't get my weight all the way to the outside on my left foot so at the T finish I was in one wicked "reverse C". You know the feeling you get when you know the outcome before hand, that was me,lol. So today, I'm paying for it but I should be good to go about Sunday.
Thanks for the report and continued success.
Boog

Robert Thompson's picture

Submitted by Robert Thompson (not verified) on

Hi Kevin,

I just walked in the door, sat down and you cracked me up!

I snuck in a couple of laps at Tanglewood (par 27) this afternoon, and on the second round, posted a 30.  If I hadn't lost a ball on the eighth hole, I would have had a good chance at 28.  That follows up a 30 on Wednesday.  I'm feeling pretty good with my irons, chipping and putting going into tomorrow.  I'll be playing a tourney in Palmer, so wish me luck.

Hit'em Long and Straight,
Bob

Kevin McGarrahan's picture

Submitted by Kevin McGarrahan (not verified) on

Nor do I necessarily disagree with you. I'm just quoting the Foundations Manual.

Kevin McGarrahan's picture

Submitted by Kevin McGarrahan (not verified) on

I went outside and hit some balls earlier, trying out what I experimented with yesterday. What I identified to work on works really well. Instead of using my 7-iron, I went with the 8-iron and was hitting balls as far as I was hitting my 7-iron yesterday. The only problem I seem to have, and it affects everything else, is intro­ducing tension either during the forward press or the shift
right. I tend to push down with my hands as I am doing the forward press. That causes my arms and shoulder to tighten up and my upper body to dip toward the ball. I need to be aware of that and fix it before I swing. The other tension producer is slouching when I slide the two inches right to pre-load heavy right. The only way I know to describe it is that movement that Annika Sorenstam did after hitting her opening tee shot at Colonial a couple of years ago. It is sort of a sink­ing down on the right side with an excessive tilt of the spine to the right and back slightly. If I can avoid both of those tendencies or at least learn how to stop my swing as I do them, I believe I can see a drastic improvement in my golf swing.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Hal, Some people are just natural born whiners. They prefer to bitch and whine about all the free things in life, yet they're still the first in line to get all of the hand outs. Strange folks indeed and very hard to figure out or please.  Cheers

Kevin McGarrahan's picture

Submitted by Kevin McGarrahan (not verified) on

For all Surgites,

I know this has been said before, but it bears repeating. Ignore the negative comments and be civil. There are a lot of people who like to instigate intense discussions. When we have a knee-jerk reaction to that instigation, we serve only to perpetuate. I doubt that Don or DJ would react this way, so, since it is Don's site, let's comport ourselves as Don does. May peace descend upon and remain in the Surge Nation.

During this Memorial Day weekend, please remember all those who have made the ultimate sacrifice so that we can have animated discussions without fear of reprisal.

Kevin

Dmaherda's picture

Submitted by Dmaherda (not verified) on

I for one LIKE the instruction from the 19th hole.

Keith Kent's picture

Submitted by Keith Kent (not verified) on

More than a slight fade with the driver, I am battling the outside in path and just not got the dropping of the club at the top to get it in the right position pre impact. I know in my head how the swing needs to be but doing it is another matter.
Repetition and trying is the key hopefully, if I know what I should be doing I am halfway there right?,
I have studdied it that much in the last 9 months I am sure I could teach the Surge swing!Lol
Just not mastered it yet, but I will. 

Carysbluesky's picture

Submitted by Carysbluesky (not verified) on

After investing in the Tour Striker, which causes me to hit down on the ball, my distance and accuracy improved.  If the theory behind the Tour Striker is wrong, (hitting down on the ball) why has its use caused my stroke to improve?  Further more, why is there disagreement over the issue of hitting down.  I've heard different Pros advocate hitting down, and then some like yourself call it "Rubbish."  How does one argue with success?  I do agree, if one hits down on the ball, and hits it "fat" it does sting.

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

David,  Below the video discourse, in the last sentence, you will see TRY CLICKING HERE, highlighted in blue. Give that a try. Also, just below the video, to the left of the video enlargement icon, you will see a UTUBE ICON, just click on that to watch the Utube version. There are a few videos between 5/28 and 5/30, in which the last sentence of the discourse has a click here with the HERE IN GREEN to click for the Utube version. I think the new posts since 1 June, will be around for a while. If that does not work for you, you can still view ALL of the VIDEOS at this host utube site. Good luck.
http://www.youtube.com/user/sw...

dgaines's picture

Submitted by dgaines on

Keith it looks like your left knee is turning back behind the ball that is allowing the over rotation and getting the club laid off. You may be sliding back in your BUS too.
Work on preloaded heavy right and keeping the outer pressure on the knees and minimal movement in them.

This is just my humble opinion.

But your swing looks pretty smooth. Hard to believe you are only 9 months in. Keep up the good work and keep posting the videos.

I took my 3wood to a driving range today. Range at my course is rather short and you fire over a hill so hard to get a feel of actual flight. Took the camera too, but, forgot to charge the batteries so no video. Raced through the bucket of balls because I was getting chewed up by black flies. Was working on vertical BUS, quiet legs, bump and T-finish. It certainly felt good and had mostly great shots.

Dan

TinaB's picture

Submitted by TinaB (not verified) on

Steve,
I think there was a golfer (I'm thinking it was Lee Trevino, who got struck by lightning?) that "only God can hit a 1 iron."     :)

Don's picture

Submitted by Don on

I'm 71 and a new golfer. I love "Surge" and listen to his instructions but would like to see an actual demonstration of his swing techniques. Is that coming?

Jpkandra's picture

Submitted by Jpkandra (not verified) on

look  when i got 2 hole in ones  within 5 days on different courses  , after  i was told by a pro to pick a spot in front of the ball   and  make sure you just schim the grass that way the club is comming down to the ball at a decending angle . i have been doing that and hitting the ball criisp and straight  and found out my 7 iron now travels easy 150 yds  whereas before i would get oly about 130 yds max    being a 86 yr old  golfer evry body tells me they would like to play like me when they are 86  jpkandra sr

tiptoeskst's picture

Submitted by tiptoeskst on

You are getting caught up in semantics.  Of course gravity dictates that if you go up you must come down.  Surge would never deny that.  His intention in saying "Don't hit down" is not to focus all your energy into the downswing but rather the forward upswing.  It is not terrible advice.  It is part of the very foundation of the Surge Swing, and is excellent advice for those who interpret it correctly.

Keith's picture

Submitted by Keith on

Unless he's come up with something different since I got his videos, that's not what he teaches.  He always says you make your turn to the toe line then lift your arms straight up.  If the club goes behind the toe line it's in the SBG and you're DEAD!  I've never heard him say anything like what you just said.

Keith E's picture

Submitted by Keith E (not verified) on

Not bad for 9 mos.!  I'm no expert by any means and have only been working on the Surge swing a few months myself (played quite a bit before that, though). In your comments, you noted that you have a bit of a wrist flip on the BUS.  Hard to confirm that from the lighting but, based on where you are at the top I think it's safe to say that you've got a bit more rotation than you want for the Surge swing (a battle I fight myself almost CONSTANTLY) and it's putting you into the SBG.  I've found that a reminder that Don & DJ used in the videos helps me a bit --- "It's a little bit of turn and a lot of lift." 

BTW -- I find that running video of my swing side by side with the ones from Don & DJ really helps me pick up and fix my issues. 

Keep it vertical,
Keith

T Medley's picture

Submitted by T Medley (not verified) on

Ian,  LAZY, REALLY!  How much are you paying for these daily videos. Don takes the time out of his busy schedule, to give you FREE daily video tips, each and every busy day of his valuable time, and YOU are such a selfish little *#+*, that you call him lazy for doing it, FOR FREE. In reality, if you were not so lazy and cheap, you could learn how to navigate this site, the Utube site, and find numerous video lessons from Don on the course. Or, you could buy his actual lesson videos and manual with his on course instructions, which you desire.  Here's a novel thought, do something to help yourself, or just move on to another site.

Kevin McGarrahan's picture

Submitted by Kevin McGarrahan (not verified) on

Once again, I am choosing to answer myself, just because I can. Instead of trying just to make perfect swings, I decided to experiment with individual changes. I went through about 150 balls in the process. Please pardon the length of this post, but I thought some of you might find it interesting.

1) Position of hands at address - I experimented with my hands in three positions and hit 10 balls in each. The first position was hands centered on my body. This put them about 1 inch in front of the ball. The second was forward with the left arm and the club shaft in a straight line to the ball. Position three was a combination of the first two - address the ball with the hands in the middle and initiate (trigger) the swing with a forward press to straighten the left wrist. For position 1, I had a tendency to compensate and try to straighten the wrist at TOBS. This caused a fairly large laying-off and an over-the-top move, resulting in 8 of 10 balls being pulled 20 yards left and the other 2 were 30 yard slices. Position 2 seemed to cause me to raise my hands up to initiate the swing. This in turn caused my wrists to be loose through out the swing with minimal control. I sprayed the ball all over the place - short, left, right, long, everywhere but on target. Finally, in position 3, the slight forward press (with emphasis on slight), preset my wrist angle, set the firmness of my wrists and allowed for a smooth turn away from address, all the way to TOBS. 9 of 10 balls were on the target line and in a 15-foot circle, just short of the target.

2) Pre-loaded heavy right. This is something I have had a great problem figuring out, so I decided to get technical. I brought my bathroom scale outside and got a block of wood from the workshop that was the same thickness. I weighed myself (190) and figured 60% (114). I put the block of wood under my left foot and the scale under my right. I took my stance and shifted my weight to the right until the scale read 114. I then hit 10 balls that way, resetting between each shot, of course. Maintaining the 114 as close as possible made the bump occur quite naturally and all 10 balls went target high (+/- 3 ft) with a spread of 9 yards from left to right. I then increased the heavy right to about 70% (135) and repeated the experiment. The additional preloading to the right caused me to lunge at the ball. 8 of 10 balls were weak banana slices with a significant loss of distance. Being so far right to start, I would sway outside my right foot and could not get back. The final test in this group was with my weight at 50% (95). With these shots, 7 of 10 were also over the top, but because I would be falling forward, I was hitting pulls and pull hooks.

3) Transition at TOBS. This part was not quite as scientific, but more mental and feel. I hit the first 10 balls, trying to think of absolutely nothing. I managed that on 7 of 10 shots. The problem was that I had no control over the tension level in my swing. 0 of 10 shots were bad. Once again, I sprayed them all over the place, to a far greater extent than in previous tries. For the second 10 shots, I concentrated on Surge's "Ring the Bell" tip. On all 10 shots, I sort of got stuck at the TOBS and jerked the club down, but not straight down. This jerk caused me to immediately spin out to the left and hit 10 exceedingly bad banana slices. For the third set, my transition thought, which occurred during the BUS, was "skip the stone." All 10 shots were straight (+/- 5 yards) and 5-10 yards past the target.

4) Combination of 1 and 2. I used the forward press with the 60% heavy right. 8 of 10 shots were on target (10-ft circle). One was long (5-yd) left (5-yd), and the 10th was 10 yards short.

5) Combination of 1 and 3 - forward press with skipping the stone and weight at 50%. I tended to reverse tilt on the take-away and hit 8 of 10 shots fat - 2-6 inches behind the ball. On the other two, I completely lost my balance, getting out on my toes and hitting the dreaded shanks.

6) Combination of 2 and 3 - 60% heavy right with skipping the stone and hands neutral. 9 of 10 shots were dead straight and 4 of 10 hit the target (my mail box). With these shots, I was able to stay far more relaxed throughout the shots than in the other experiments.

7) 60% heavy right, forward press, skipping the stone. 6 of 10 shots hit the mailbox. The other 4 were within 10 feet.

8) Same as #7, except increasing the TOBS from 12 o'clock to 1 o'clock as view from face on. All shots went 10-12 yards over the target. Deviation was 3 yards right to 8 yards left. The slightly longer backswing seemed to encourage a slight draw.

9) Same as #7, except increasing the TOBS to 2 o'clock as view from face on. I past the point of diminishing returns - distance control and direction control both went out the window. 10 of 10 shots were well away from the target. Balance was extremely hard to maintain.

I guess I now know what I need to work on.

Kevin
 

Steve Smith's picture

Submitted by Steve Smith on

I really am thinking about getting one. How well I hit fairway woods compared to irons seems to run in cycles and stays fairly predictable for a while.
Those times when I am in an "iron cycle" (LOL) I could put it in the bag.
Darn! Who invented the rule about how many clubs we could have in the bag. LMAO

P.S. I am in the process of another experiment right at this minute that just might solve my driver problems.
Too early for publication but maybe I'll have something on it tomorrow. ;-)
(I feel good about it's chances).

Pages